TL;DR: Tithe.ly is a solid all-in-one platform for US churches, but it’s not the right fit for everyone. If you need modular flexibility, pick Planning Center. If you want the simplest ChMS on the market, go with Breeze. If you need a premium giving experience for a large church, look at Pushpay. Here are all 7 alternatives with honest pricing and trade-offs.
Why Churches Look for Tithe.ly Alternatives
We gave Tithe.ly a thorough review. The All-Access plan at $119/month is genuinely good value for US churches that want giving, a ChMS, a custom app, and a website in one package. But “good for most US churches” still leaves a lot of churches looking for something different.
Here are the four reasons that come up most often.
1. You Want a Modular Approach, Not a Bundle
Tithe.ly’s value proposition is the bundle. But bundles cut both ways. If you only need a strong ChMS and don’t care about a branded app or website builder, you’re paying for features you won’t use.
Some churches prefer to pick the best tool for each job rather than accept a single vendor’s version of everything. Planning Center’s modular approach exists specifically for this reason.
2. Transaction Fees Add Up
Tithe.ly charges 2.9% + $0.30 per credit card transaction and 1.0% + $0.30 for ACH. On $15,000/month in digital giving, that’s roughly $465 in monthly fees on cards alone.
The “Cover the Fees” feature helps (about 60% of donors opt in), but not every church is comfortable asking members to absorb processing costs. Some platforms offer lower base rates, negotiated pricing, or flat-rate options that work out cheaper at higher volumes.
3. You Need More Feature Depth
Tithe.ly covers a lot of ground, but it doesn’t go deep in every area. The worship planning tools are basic compared to Planning Center Services. Reporting and analytics lag behind enterprise platforms like Pushpay + CCB. Automation is limited to simple follow-ups rather than multi-step workflows.
If your church has outgrown “good enough” in a specific area, a more specialized tool might serve you better.
4. You’re Outside North America
This is the biggest gap. Tithe.ly only supports credit/debit cards and ACH bank transfers. There’s no M-Pesa, no mobile money, no multi-currency giving, and no WhatsApp integration.
For churches in Africa, Latin America, the Caribbean, or Asia, these aren’t nice-to-haves. They’re essentials. We’ve written extensively about why US church software doesn’t work for African churches, and the pattern holds for Tithe.ly too.
The 7 Best Tithe.ly Alternatives
1. Planning Center: Best Modular Platform
Best for: Mid-to-large churches that want to pick and choose features instead of buying a bundle.
Planning Center is the anti-bundle. Instead of one all-in-one package, you get eight separate apps that work together: People, Services, Giving, Groups, Registrations, Check-Ins, Calendar, and Publishing. Use the ones you need. Skip the rest.
The standout is Planning Center Services, which is the best worship planning tool in the industry. Song databases, musician scheduling with conflict detection, chord chart management, CCLI reporting, and ProPresenter integration. Tithe.ly’s worship tools don’t come close.
Pricing:
| App | Starting Price |
|---|---|
| People | Free (up to 100 profiles) |
| Services | Free (basic) |
| Giving | No monthly fee (transaction fees only) |
| Groups | $20/month |
| Check-Ins | Free (basic) |
| Calendar | $10/month |
| Registrations | $10/month |
A typical mid-size church using most apps pays $100-200/month.
What it does better than Tithe.ly:
- Worship planning is in a different league
- More advanced automated workflows
- 30+ integrations (ProPresenter, CCLI, QuickBooks, Zapier)
- Generous free tier for small churches
- Stronger check-in system for children’s ministry
What it does worse:
- No custom branded church app (Church Center is functional but generic)
- No website builder
- Managing 8 separate apps can feel fragmented
- Giving experience isn’t as polished as Tithe.ly’s
- Still US-centric with no WhatsApp or mobile money support
Best for: Churches that care about worship planning, want modular pricing, or need deeper automation. Read our full Planning Center review or see how they compare in our Tithe.ly vs Planning Center breakdown.
2. Breeze: Best for Simplicity
Best for: Small churches (under 300 members) that just want something that works without a learning curve.
Breeze is technically part of the Tithe.ly family (acquired in 2021), but it still operates as its own product at breezechms.com. If Tithe.ly feels like too much platform for your church, Breeze strips it back to the essentials.
What you get:
- Member database with custom fields and family grouping
- Online giving and donor management
- Event management with check-ins
- Groups and volunteer coordination
- Email and text communication
- Follow-up tracking
Pricing: $72/month flat. Unlimited members, unlimited users. No tiers, no surprises.
What it does better than Tithe.ly:
- Radically simpler to set up and use (an afternoon vs. a week)
- Flat pricing with no feature confusion
- Perfect for churches that don’t need an app, website, or worship tools
What it does worse:
- No custom church app
- No website builder
- No worship planning at all
- Giving tools are solid but simpler than Tithe.ly’s
- Limited automation
- US-only giving and communication
Best for: The church that tried Tithe.ly All-Access and realized they only used 30% of the features. If your needs are member management, basic giving, and communication, Breeze does it without the bloat. Read our full Breeze review.
3. Pushpay: Best for Large Churches
Best for: Churches with 1,000+ members that need premium giving analytics and enterprise-grade tools.
Pushpay (which acquired Church Community Builder in 2019, now private under Sixth Street Partners and BGH Capital) sits at the opposite end of the market from Tithe.ly. Where Tithe.ly competes on value, Pushpay competes on depth. The giving experience is the most polished in the industry. One-tap Quick Give, donor engagement scoring, and advanced giving analytics give finance teams real data to work with.
The CCB side brings enterprise church management: advanced process queues (automated workflows), detailed reporting, and robust multi-campus support.
Estimated Pricing:
| Package | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|
| Pushpay Giving Only | $199-399/month |
| Pushpay + Church App | $399-799/month |
| Pushpay + CCB (full suite) | $500-1,500+/month |
Annual contracts are typical. Pricing requires a sales call.
What it does better than Tithe.ly:
- Strong giving UX (Quick Give, donor engagement scoring)
- Advanced giving analytics and reporting
- Premium branded church app
- CCB’s automation workflows are far deeper
- Strongest multi-campus support
What it does worse:
- 4-10x more expensive
- Quote-based pricing with no transparency
- Annual contracts lock you in
- The CCB interface feels dated
- Still no WhatsApp, mobile money, or global payment support
Best for: Large US churches where maximizing giving revenue justifies the premium price. If your church processes $50,000+/month in digital giving, Pushpay’s optimized giving flow can potentially pay for itself. For everyone else, the math doesn’t work. See our Pushpay vs Tithe.ly comparison for the full breakdown.
4. Subsplash: Best for Apps and Media
Best for: Churches that prioritize a premium mobile app, live streaming, and sermon content.
Subsplash makes the best custom church apps on the market. If your church’s mobile presence is a top priority, Subsplash delivers polished, fully branded iOS and Android apps that look like they were built by a professional studio.
The real differentiator in 2026 is Pulpit AI. Upload a sermon, and it automatically generates blog posts, social media clips, video highlights, discussion guides, and more. For churches producing weekly sermon content, this is a genuine time-saver.
Pricing: Quote-based for most packages. Giving is free ($0/month, transaction fees only). App packages start around $99/month with a $499 setup fee. Full Subsplash One bundles require a custom quote.
Transaction fees: 2.9% + $0.30 (cards), 1.0% (ACH), with GrowCurve rates as low as 1.9% for high-volume churches.
What it does better than Tithe.ly:
- Premium app quality (the best in the industry)
- Live streaming and media hosting (HD, 4K, Roku, Apple TV, Fire TV)
- Pulpit AI for automated sermon-to-content repurposing
- GrowCurve rates can beat Tithe.ly’s transaction fees at high volume
What it does worse:
- Quote-based pricing makes budgeting harder
- Setup fees add to initial cost
- The ChMS is less mature than Tithe.ly’s (formerly Breeze) engine
- Website builder (SnapPages) is the weakest in the space
- Also US-centric with no global payment or WhatsApp support
Best for: Media-heavy churches that invest in sermon content, video production, and want a top-tier mobile app. If your church streams services, publishes podcast episodes, and creates social media clips from sermons, Subsplash’s media tools and Pulpit AI add real value that Tithe.ly can’t match. Read our full Subsplash review.
5. ChurchTrac: Best Budget Option
Best for: Small churches on tight budgets that need solid church management without the price tag.
ChurchTrac has been quietly serving churches since 2002. It doesn’t have the marketing budget of Tithe.ly or the brand recognition of Planning Center, but it delivers a surprisingly complete feature set at prices that make other platforms look expensive.
What you get:
- Member management with families, groups, and custom fields
- Contribution tracking and donor management
- Attendance tracking and check-ins
- Worship planning (in the Plus plan)
- Communication tools (email and SMS)
- Online giving integration
- Built-in accounting tools
- Volunteer scheduling
Pricing:
| Plan | Cost | Members |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0/month | Up to 100 |
| Standard | $7/month | Unlimited (giving, check-in) |
| Plus | $15/month | Unlimited (advanced reports, custom fields, integrations) |
Transaction fees: 2.9% + $0.30 (cards), 1.0% + $0.30 (ACH).
What it does better than Tithe.ly:
- The price difference is massive ($15/month vs. $119/month for comparable features)
- Free plan is real and usable (100 people with core functionality)
- Includes worship planning in the Plus plan
- Built-in accounting tools that Tithe.ly doesn’t offer
What it does worse:
- No custom church app
- Interface is functional but dated
- Limited integrations with third-party tools
- No advanced donor analytics
- No live streaming or media features
- US-centric with no global payment support
Best for: Budget-conscious churches under 250 members. If you’re paying $119/month for Tithe.ly All-Access but only using member management, giving, and basic communication, ChurchTrac Plus at $15/month covers those same needs and saves your church over $1,000/year.
6. Elvanto (UCare): Best for International Churches
Best for: Churches in Australia, New Zealand, the UK, and other non-US markets that need a platform built beyond North America.
Elvanto, now part of the UCare ecosystem, comes out of Australia and offers something most US-built church platforms don’t: a genuine international perspective. It supports multiple currencies, has a cleaner global payment setup, and the support team operates outside US time zones.
What you get:
- Member database with families, groups, and custom fields
- Worship planning and service management
- Volunteer rostering (scheduling) with availability tracking
- Online giving with broader currency support
- Groups, events, and communication tools
- Multi-site support
- Reporting and analytics
Pricing: Per-person pricing based on active member count. Starts around $50/month for small churches and scales with congregation size.
What it does better than Tithe.ly:
- Worship planning and volunteer rostering included
- Better international support (Australia, New Zealand, UK, and beyond)
- Clean, modern interface with solid feature depth
What it does worse:
- Per-person pricing can get expensive for larger churches
- No WhatsApp integration
- Limited mobile money support
- Australian time zone for primary support
- Smaller ecosystem and community than Tithe.ly
Best for: Churches in Australia, New Zealand, the UK, or Europe that need worship planning and a platform that wasn’t built exclusively for American churches. For US churches, Planning Center generally offers better value at similar depth.
7. Givelify: Best Free Giving App
Best for: Churches that only need a simple, free giving app without a full ChMS.
Givelify is the alternative for churches that don’t want or need all-in-one. It’s a standalone giving app, available on iOS and Android, that lets members donate to your church in about 10 seconds. No website integration needed. No ChMS bundled in. Just giving.
The app is free for churches to list on, and it comes with a built-in donor network. Members can discover your church through the app itself, which is a unique advantage that platform-specific tools like Tithe.ly don’t offer.
What you get:
- Free giving app (iOS and Android)
- Recurring giving and one-time donations
- Fund designation for multiple campaigns
- Donor management dashboard
- Giving reports and tax statements
- Built-in church directory for donor discovery
Pricing: No monthly fee. Transaction fees are 2.9% + $0.30 per donation. That’s the same card rate as Tithe.ly, but with no monthly subscription at all.
What it does better than Tithe.ly:
- Zero monthly cost (transaction fees only, no subscription)
- Simplest donor experience (download the app, search the church, give)
- Built-in donor discovery through the Givelify network
- No setup or technical knowledge required
What it does worse:
- No ChMS, no member management, no check-ins
- No custom branding (your church appears inside the Givelify app)
- No text-to-give
- Limited donor analytics compared to Tithe.ly
- No church app, website, or worship tools
- US-focused with no mobile money or WhatsApp support
Best for: Small churches, church plants, or congregations that only need digital giving and nothing else. If you’re currently paying $72-119/month for Tithe.ly but only using the giving features, Givelify gives you that specific functionality for $0/month.
Master Comparison Table
Here’s how all 7 Tithe.ly alternatives stack up side by side.
| Feature | Tithe.ly | Planning Center | Breeze | Pushpay + CCB | Subsplash | ChurchTrac | Elvanto/UCare | Givelify |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $119 (All-Access) | $100-200+ | $72 | $500-1,500+ | Quote-based | $0-30 | $50-150+ | $0 (fees only) |
| Transparent Pricing | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Annual Contract | No | No | No | Yes | Varies | No | No | No |
| Online Giving | Strong | Good | Solid | Best-in-class | Strong | Basic | Good | Simple and easy |
| Custom Church App | Included | Church Center | No | Premium | Best-in-class | No | No | No (Givelify app) |
| ChMS Depth | Mid | Deep | Simple | Deep (CCB) | Basic-Mid | Mid | Good | None |
| Worship Planning | Basic | Best-in-class | None | None | None | Good (Plus) | Good | None |
| Donor Analytics | Basic | Good | Basic | Best-in-class | Basic | Basic | Basic | Basic |
| Live Streaming | Good | No | No | No | Excellent | No | No | No |
| AI Content Tools | No | No | No | No | Pulpit AI | No | No | No |
| No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | |
| Mobile Money | No | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
| Multi-Currency | No | No | No | No | No | No | Basic | No |
| Free Plan | Yes (giving) | Yes (limited) | No | No | Yes (giving) | Yes (100 people) | No | Yes (all giving) |
| Best For | US all-in-one | Modular / worship | Small + simple | Large US churches | Apps + media | Ultra-budget | AU/NZ/UK churches | Free giving only |
Giving Only vs. Full ChMS vs. All-in-One: Which Do You Need?
Before picking a Tithe.ly alternative, figure out what category of tool you actually need. This matters more than any feature comparison.
Giving Only
You need: A way to accept online donations. That’s it.
Best picks: Givelify (free, simplest setup) or Planning Center Giving (free, integrates if you add other PC apps later).
This is the right choice for churches that already have a ChMS they’re happy with, or churches so small that a spreadsheet handles member management. Don’t pay for a full platform when you only need one feature.
Full ChMS (No Giving Focus)
You need: Member management, groups, check-ins, communication, and possibly worship planning. Giving is secondary or handled separately.
Best picks: Planning Center (deepest feature set), Breeze (simplest), or ChurchTrac (cheapest).
This works well for churches that want to separate their giving platform from their management platform. Many churches run Planning Center for operations and a separate giving tool they prefer.
All-in-One
You need: Everything under one roof. Giving, ChMS, app, website, communication, and ideally worship planning.
Best picks: Tithe.ly All-Access ($119/month) is actually the best value here for US churches. If you want premium quality in every category, Subsplash One or Pushpay + CCB deliver that at a higher price.
The trade-off is always depth vs. breadth. All-in-one platforms give you convenience, but the individual components rarely match the best standalone tools in each category.
The Global Perspective
Every platform in this article shares one limitation: they were built for churches in the United States (or in Elvanto’s case, Australia). The core assumptions are the same. Members have credit cards. Communication happens over email. Internet connections are reliable. Everyone speaks English.
For the majority of the world’s 2+ billion Christians, those assumptions don’t hold.
In East Africa, M-Pesa processes more transactions than many banks. A giving platform that only accepts Visa and Mastercard misses most donors.
In West Africa and Latin America, WhatsApp is the primary communication channel with 98%+ open rates. Email newsletters go unread.
In South Asia and the Caribbean, mobile-first access is the norm. Heavy web apps built for desktop browsers don’t work well on low-bandwidth connections.
If your church operates in any of these contexts, or serves a diaspora community with members giving from multiple countries, the US-built platforms in this article will leave significant gaps. This isn’t a knock on them. They built excellent tools for their target market. But if your church isn’t in that market, you need something different.
Our Verdict
The best Tithe.ly alternative depends entirely on why you’re leaving.
If you want modular flexibility: Planning Center. Pay for what you use. Skip what you don’t. The worship planning alone is worth the switch if that’s a priority.
If you want radical simplicity: Breeze. $72/month, flat rate, learn it in a day. Perfect for small churches that found Tithe.ly’s All-Access too much platform.
If you want premium giving for a large church: Pushpay. The most polished giving experience on the market. The price is steep, but large churches with significant digital giving volume may see the ROI.
If you want the best church app and media tools: Subsplash. Premium apps, excellent streaming, and Pulpit AI for sermon content. Worth the conversation if media is central to your ministry.
If budget is your top priority: ChurchTrac. Free for up to 100 people. $15/month for unlimited people with worship planning included. Hard to beat on value.
If you only need giving: Givelify. Zero monthly cost. Download, list your church, start receiving donations today.
If you’re outside North America: Keep reading.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest Tithe.ly alternative?
ChurchTrac offers a free plan for up to 100 people and a Plus plan at $15/month with unlimited people. For giving-only, both Givelify and Planning Center Giving charge zero monthly fees (transaction fees only). These are the most budget-friendly options.
Can I migrate my data from Tithe.ly to another platform?
Yes. Tithe.ly supports CSV exports for member data, giving history, and other records. Most alternatives (Planning Center, Breeze, ChurchTrac, Elvanto) accept CSV imports. The migration typically takes 1-2 weeks including testing. Start the process while your Tithe.ly account is still active so you have access to all your data.
Is Planning Center better than Tithe.ly?
It depends on your priorities. Planning Center is better for worship planning, automation, and modular pricing. Tithe.ly is better for bundled value, the giving experience, and getting a custom app included in your subscription. For a detailed head-to-head, read our Tithe.ly vs Planning Center comparison.
Does Tithe.ly work for churches outside the US?
Tithe.ly supports giving in select countries (Australia, UK, Singapore, Japan, Hong Kong, New Zealand) via credit/debit cards. However, there’s no mobile money, no WhatsApp integration, no multi-currency giving, and no regional payment methods for Africa or Latin America. For global churches, the platform has significant gaps.
What happens to my recurring donors if I switch from Tithe.ly?
Recurring donors will need to set up their recurring gifts again on the new platform. Most churches run both platforms for 1-3 months during transition. Communicate the switch clearly, provide step-by-step instructions for setting up recurring giving on the new platform, and don’t turn off Tithe.ly until the majority of recurring givers have transitioned.
Is there a Tithe.ly alternative with WhatsApp support?
Among the platforms in this comparison, none of the US-built alternatives support WhatsApp natively. Read our deep dive on WhatsApp as a church communication tool for more on this topic.
Can I use Tithe.ly’s free giving alongside another ChMS?
Yes. Tithe.ly’s free giving plan works independently of their ChMS. Many churches use Tithe.ly for giving while running Planning Center, ChurchTrac, or another platform for member management. This is a legitimate approach if you like Tithe.ly’s giving experience but need a different ChMS.
Which alternative is best for a church plant?
For a US church plant with minimal budget, start with ChurchTrac’s free plan for management and Givelify for giving. Total cost: $0/month. As you grow, upgrade to ChurchTrac Plus ($15/month) or evaluate Tithe.ly’s All-Access plan when you need an app and website.