TL;DR: Pushpay is a premium church giving platform, but the pricing, annual contracts, and the CCB merger have pushed many churches to look elsewhere. We tested 7 Pushpay alternatives that offer better value, more flexibility, or global support. Tithe.ly is the best all-around replacement for most US churches. Planning Center wins for operational depth. Here’s the full breakdown.
Why Churches Are Leaving Pushpay
Before we get into alternatives, it helps to understand why so many churches are looking for one. Based on user reviews, community discussions, and our own research, three reasons come up over and over.
1. The Price Is Too High
This is the number one reason churches leave Pushpay. Full stop.
Pushpay’s estimated pricing ranges from $199/month for giving-only to $500-1,500+/month for the full Pushpay + CCB bundle. That’s 4-10x what most alternatives charge. For a mid-size church doing $10,000/month in digital giving, spending $600+/month on the platform collecting it is hard to justify to a finance committee.
Annual contracts make this worse. You’re locked in for 12 months before you know if the ROI is there. And when renewal time comes, some churches report price increases with limited room to negotiate.
2. The CCB Merger Created Confusion
When Pushpay acquired Church Community Builder (CCB) in December 2019, it was supposed to create a best-of-both-worlds platform. Giving excellence meets church management depth.
In reality, the integration has been bumpy. Users report inconsistent interfaces between the Pushpay and CCB sides, data sync issues, and a learning curve that comes from stitching together two products built by different teams. The 2023 acquisition by Sixth Street Partners and BGH Capital (taking Pushpay private) added another layer of uncertainty about product direction, support quality, and long-term pricing.
Some churches that were happy Pushpay customers for years started shopping around after the acquisition. Not because the giving tools got worse, but because the overall experience became more complex and less predictable.
3. No Global Support
Pushpay only supports credit/debit cards and ACH bank transfers. No M-Pesa. No mobile money. No multi-currency giving. No WhatsApp integration.
For churches outside North America, or US churches with international members, this is a dealbreaker. We’ve covered this in depth in our article on why US church software doesn’t work for African churches.
The 7 Best Pushpay Alternatives
1. Tithe.ly: Best Overall Pushpay Replacement
Best for: Churches that want everything Pushpay offers at a fraction of the cost.
Tithe.ly is the most direct Pushpay alternative on the market. It started as a mobile giving platform (just like Pushpay), but has grown into a full church management suite after acquiring Breeze ChMS in 2021.
What you get:
- Online giving with text-to-give, recurring gifts, and donor management
- Church management (formerly Breeze) with member database, groups, and check-ins
- Custom branded church app (iOS and Android)
- Church website builder
- Worship planning tools
- All bundled together for $119/month on the All-Access plan
Pricing:
| Plan | Cost |
|---|---|
| Free Giving | $0/month (transaction fees only) |
| Church Management + Giving (formerly Breeze) | $72/month |
| All-Access (everything) | $119/month |
Transaction fees: 2.9% + $0.30 (cards), 1.0% + $0.30 (ACH). The “Cover the Fees” feature lets donors absorb the cost, and about 60% opt in.
Why churches switch from Pushpay to Tithe.ly:
- 80-90% cost savings. The All-Access plan at $119/month replaces a Pushpay + CCB bundle that costs $500-1,500+/month.
- Transparent pricing. No sales calls, no custom quotes. You can see costs and sign up today.
- No annual contracts. Month-to-month flexibility.
- The giving experience is strong. Not quite as polished as Pushpay’s Quick Give, but close enough that most congregations won’t notice the difference.
Where it falls short compared to Pushpay:
- Donor analytics and engagement scoring aren’t as deep
- The church app is good, not premium-tier like Pushpay’s
- Worship planning tools are basic compared to dedicated solutions
The bottom line: For most churches leaving Pushpay, Tithe.ly is the easiest switch. You get giving, a ChMS, an app, and a website for less than what Pushpay charges for giving alone. Read our full Tithe.ly review for the deep dive.
2. Breeze: Best for Small Churches That Want Simplicity
Best for: Small churches (under 300 members) that just need the basics done well.
Breeze is now part of the Tithe.ly family, but it still operates as its own product at breezechms.com. It’s the simplest church management platform on the market, and that’s exactly the point.
What you get:
- Member database with custom fields, families, and tagging
- Online giving and donor management
- Event management with check-ins
- Groups and volunteer coordination
- Email and text communication
- Follow-up tracking
Pricing: $72/month flat. Unlimited members, unlimited users. No add-ons, no surprises.
Why churches switch from Pushpay to Breeze:
- Radical simplicity. If CCB’s complex interface drove you crazy, Breeze is the antidote. Setup takes an afternoon, not a week.
- Predictable pricing. One number. Every month. No contract negotiations.
- It does what most small churches actually need. Member management, giving, communication, check-ins. Nothing more, nothing less.
Where it falls short compared to Pushpay:
- No custom church app
- No donor analytics or engagement scoring
- Giving tools are solid but not as optimized as Pushpay’s
- No live streaming or media features
- Limited automation capabilities
The bottom line: Breeze is perfect for the church that was using Pushpay because someone sold them on it, but in reality, they only needed 30% of the features. If you’re a small church that values simplicity over power, Breeze delivers. Read our full Breeze review.
3. Planning Center: Best for Operational Depth
Best for: Mid-to-large churches that need worship planning, check-ins, and modular flexibility.
Planning Center takes a completely different approach than Pushpay. Instead of one bundled platform, it offers eight separate apps that work together: People, Services, Giving, Groups, Registrations, Check-Ins, Calendar, and Publishing.
What you get:
- The best worship planning tool in the industry (Services)
- A mature member database with workflows and automation (People)
- Modular pricing where you only pay for what you use
- A free tier for small churches
- Strong check-in system for children’s ministry
- Church Center app for member self-service
Pricing:
| App | Starting Price |
|---|---|
| People | Free (up to 100 profiles) |
| Services | Free (basic) |
| Giving | No monthly fee, transaction fees only |
| Groups | $20/month |
| Check-Ins | Free (basic) |
| Calendar | $10/month |
| Registrations | $10/month |
| Publishing | Free (basic) |
A typical mid-size church using most apps pays $100-200/month.
Why churches switch from Pushpay to Planning Center:
- You only pay for what you use. If you don’t need groups or registrations, don’t buy them.
- Worship planning is unmatched. Planning Center Services is the most established worship planning tool available. Pushpay doesn’t even have worship planning.
- Transparent pricing. Published rates, no sales calls needed.
- The free tier is real. Small churches can use People, Services, Giving, and Check-Ins for free or very low cost.
Where it falls short compared to Pushpay:
- No custom branded church app (Church Center is functional, not premium)
- The giving experience is good, not Pushpay-level polished
- Managing multiple separate apps can feel fragmented
- No donor engagement scoring or advanced giving analytics
- Steeper learning curve than simpler platforms like Breeze
The bottom line: Planning Center is the right Pushpay alternative for churches that care about operational depth, especially worship planning and check-ins. It’s not a direct replacement for Pushpay’s giving focus, but it’s a better overall platform for churches that need more than just giving tools. Read our full Planning Center review.
4. Subsplash: Best for Media-Heavy Churches
Best for: Churches that prioritize a premium app, live streaming, and sermon content.
Subsplash competes with Pushpay in two key areas: custom church apps and digital giving. Their apps are arguably the best-looking in the space, and Pulpit AI (their sermon repurposing tool) is one of the most practical AI features in church tech right now.
What you get:
- Strong custom church app (your branding, App Store and Google Play)
- Online giving with GrowCurve rates that decrease as volume grows
- Live streaming and media hosting (HD, 4K, Roku, Apple TV, Fire TV)
- Pulpit AI for automatic sermon-to-content generation
- Groups, messaging, events, and a basic ChMS
- Church website builder (though it’s their weakest product)
Pricing: Quote-based, like Pushpay. Giving is free ($0/month), but app packages start around $99/month plus a $499 setup fee. Full Subsplash One bundles require a custom quote. Transaction fees: 2.9% + $0.30 (cards), 1.0% (ACH), with GrowCurve rates as low as 1.9% for high-volume churches.
Why churches switch from Pushpay to Subsplash:
- The app quality is comparable. If you loved Pushpay’s app, you’ll feel at home with Subsplash.
- Pulpit AI is a real differentiator. Upload a sermon, get 20+ pieces of content automatically. Blog posts, video clips, social media posts, discussion guides.
- GrowCurve giving rates. High-volume churches can get lower transaction fees than Pushpay.
- Stronger media tools. If your church produces a lot of video content, Subsplash is better equipped.
Where it falls short compared to Pushpay:
- Also quote-based pricing (same transparency issue)
- The ChMS is less mature than CCB
- Website builder (SnapPages) is weak
- Setup fees add to the initial cost
- Also US-centric with no global payment or communication support
The bottom line: Subsplash is the Pushpay alternative for churches that care most about their mobile app and media presence. It’s not necessarily cheaper, but the media tools and Pulpit AI offer capabilities Pushpay doesn’t match. Read our full Subsplash review.
5. ChurchTrac: Best Budget Option
Best for: Small churches on tight budgets that need solid church management without paying much.
ChurchTrac has been around since 2002, making it one of the longest-running church management platforms. It flies under the radar compared to flashier competitors, but it delivers a surprisingly complete feature set at rock-bottom pricing.
What you get:
- Member management with families, groups, and custom fields
- Contribution tracking and donor management
- Attendance tracking
- Check-in system for children’s ministry
- Event management
- Communication tools (email and text)
- Online giving integration
- Volunteer scheduling
- Basic reporting and analytics
Pricing:
| Plan | Cost | Members |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0/month | Up to 100 people |
| Standard | $7/month | Unlimited people (giving, check-in) |
| Plus | $15/month | Unlimited people (advanced reports, custom fields, integrations) |
Transaction fees for giving: 2.9% + $0.30 (cards), 1.0% + $0.30 (ACH).
Why churches switch from Pushpay to ChurchTrac:
- The price difference is staggering. ChurchTrac Plus at $15/month vs. Pushpay at $500+/month. For a small church, that’s thousands of dollars per year redirected to ministry.
- The free plan is real. 100 people with core features for $0/month. You can genuinely use ChurchTrac without paying anything.
- It covers the essentials. Member management, giving, attendance, check-ins, communication. No fluff.
Where it falls short compared to Pushpay:
- No custom church app
- No branded giving experience (uses a generic giving page)
- The interface is functional but dated compared to modern platforms
- Limited integrations with other tools
- No advanced donor analytics
- No live streaming or media tools
- Reports and customization options are basic
The bottom line: ChurchTrac is the Pushpay alternative for churches that realized they were massively overpaying for features they don’t use. If you’re a church of 100-250 members and your primary need is tracking members, managing giving, and communicating, ChurchTrac does it for less than the cost of a Netflix subscription. It’s not flashy, but it works.
6. Kindrid (via Stripe): Best for Tech-Savvy Churches
Best for: Churches that want maximum control over their giving setup and are comfortable with a lightweight, developer-friendly approach.
Kindrid was a church giving platform known for its clean design and text-to-give features. The company was acquired and its technology has been integrated into broader platforms, but the concept it pioneered is worth covering: using Stripe directly (or Stripe-powered tools) for church giving.
Several churches leaving Pushpay are going this route. Instead of paying for a bundled platform, they use Stripe as their payment processor and pair it with a lightweight giving page or form builder.
What you get with a Stripe-based approach:
- Full control over your giving experience and branding
- Lower transaction fees (2.9% + $0.30 for cards, 0.8% for ACH)
- Integration with virtually any website, app, or tool
- Recurring giving, fund designation, and donor management via Stripe Dashboard
- Access to Stripe’s ecosystem of plugins and integrations
- No monthly platform fees (just transaction fees)
Pricing: No monthly fee. Transaction fees only: 2.9% + $0.30 (cards), 0.8% (ACH). Stripe also supports international payments in 135+ currencies, which is a major advantage for global churches.
Why some churches take this route after Pushpay:
- Zero monthly platform fees. You only pay when donations come in.
- Complete flexibility. Build exactly the giving experience you want.
- Lower ACH fees. Stripe’s 0.8% ACH rate is among the lowest available.
- International support. Stripe processes payments in 46+ countries with 135+ currencies. If your church has international donors, this is a massive advantage over Pushpay.
Where it falls short compared to Pushpay:
- No church-specific features. No donor engagement scoring, no giving statements designed for tax deductions, no church-specific reporting out of the box.
- Requires technical knowledge. Someone on your team needs to set up and maintain the integration.
- No ChMS, no app, no communication tools. Stripe is a payment processor, not a church platform. You need separate tools for everything else.
- No text-to-give. You’d need a third-party integration for that.
- Support isn’t church-focused. Stripe’s support team won’t help you plan a stewardship campaign.
The bottom line: The Stripe approach is the Pushpay alternative for churches with a tech-savvy volunteer or staff member who wants to eliminate monthly platform fees entirely. It’s not for everyone, but for the right church, it’s the most cost-effective and flexible option available. Pair it with a free ChMS like ChurchTrac or Planning Center’s free tier, and you have a complete stack for almost nothing.
Master Comparison Table
Here’s how all 7 Pushpay alternatives stack up side by side.
| Feature | Pushpay + CCB | Tithe.ly | Breeze | Planning Center | Subsplash | ChurchTrac | Kindrid/Stripe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $500-1,500+ | $119 (All-Access) | $72 | $100-200+ | Quote-based | $0-30 | $0 (fees only) |
| Transparent Pricing | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Annual Contract | Yes | No | No | No | Varies | No | No |
| Online Giving | Best-in-class (US) | Strong | Solid | Good | Strong | Basic | Flexible (Stripe) |
| Custom Church App | Premium | Included | No | Church Center | Best-in-class | No | No |
| ChMS Depth | Deep (CCB) | Mid | Simple | Deep | Basic-Mid | Mid | None |
| Worship Planning | No | Basic | No | Best-in-class | No | No | No |
| Donor Analytics | Best-in-class | Basic | Basic | Good | Basic | Basic | Via Stripe Dashboard |
| Live Streaming | No | Good | No | No | Excellent | No | No |
| AI Content Tools | No | No | No | No | Pulpit AI | No | No |
| No | No | No | No | No | No | No | |
| Mobile Money | No | No | No | No | No | No | No |
| Multi-Currency | No | No | No | No | No | No | Yes (Stripe) |
| Free Plan | No | Yes (giving) | No | Yes (limited) | Yes (giving) | Yes (100 people) | Yes (fees only) |
| Best For | Large US churches | Budget all-in-one | Simple small churches | Operational depth | Media-heavy churches | Ultra-budget | Tech-savvy churches |
Which Pushpay Alternative Is Right for Your Church?
The best alternative depends on what drove you away from Pushpay in the first place.
If you left because of price:
Start with Tithe.ly. The All-Access plan at $119/month gives you giving, a ChMS, a church app, a website, and worship tools. That’s everything Pushpay + CCB offers (and more) at 80-90% less. If you want even more savings, ChurchTrac’s Plus plan at $15/month covers the essentials.
If you left because of the CCB merger:
Planning Center gives you modular flexibility without the baggage of a forced bundle. Use the apps you need, skip the ones you don’t. The interface is modern, the tools are mature, and you’re not locked into a single vendor’s vision of what “all-in-one” should look like.
If you left because you needed something simpler:
Breeze is the easiest ChMS on the market. If Pushpay + CCB felt like using a jet fighter to drive to the grocery store, Breeze is the reliable sedan you actually want. $72/month, everything included, learn it in a day.
If you want an app and media tools as good as Pushpay’s:
Subsplash matches Pushpay on app quality and beats it on media features. Pulpit AI alone is worth the conversation if your church produces sermon content. Just be prepared for the same quote-based pricing model.
If you want to spend as little as possible:
Combine ChurchTrac’s free plan (or $15/month for unlimited people) with Stripe for giving. Zero monthly platform fees. Your total cost is transaction fees only. This works best if you have someone on your team comfortable with basic tech setup.
If your church is outside North America:
None of the US-built alternatives on this list support WhatsApp, M-Pesa, mobile money, or pricing that reflects the global economy. See our guide to choosing church management software for region-specific recommendations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest Pushpay alternative?
ChurchTrac offers a free plan for churches with up to 100 people, and the Plus plan with unlimited people is just $15/month. If you only need giving, Stripe (no monthly fee, transaction fees only), Tithe.ly (free giving plan), and Subsplash Giving (free) are all zero-cost starting points.
Can I migrate my data from Pushpay to another platform?
Yes, but the process varies by platform. Most alternatives (Tithe.ly, Breeze, Planning Center, ChurchTrac) support CSV imports for member data and giving history. Pushpay’s data export may require working with their support team. Start the export process before your contract ends to avoid complications.
Is Tithe.ly as good as Pushpay for online giving?
Tithe.ly’s giving experience is strong and has improved significantly over the past two years. Pushpay’s giving flow is still slightly more polished, particularly the one-tap Quick Give feature and donor engagement scoring. But for most churches, the difference is marginal, and the price gap is massive. You’re saving $400-1,300/month by switching.
Does Planning Center have online giving?
Yes. Planning Center Giving has no monthly fee and charges only transaction fees. It’s not as feature-rich as Pushpay’s giving platform (no text-to-give, simpler donor management), but it integrates seamlessly with the rest of the Planning Center ecosystem.
What happens to my Pushpay data if I switch?
Export your data before your contract ends. Most churches export member lists, giving history, and donor contact information as CSV files. The receiving platform’s import tools will map those fields into their system. Budget 1-2 weeks for a clean migration, including testing and verification.
Can I use Pushpay and another platform at the same time during transition?
Yes, and this is often the smartest approach. Many churches run both platforms for 1-3 months while migrating members to the new giving system. Set up the new platform, migrate your data, then gradually direct members to the new giving links. Don’t turn off Pushpay until recurring givers have transitioned.
Is there a Pushpay alternative that works for churches in Africa?
Most US-built church platforms (Pushpay, Tithe.ly, Planning Center, Breeze, Subsplash) don’t support African payment methods like M-Pesa or mobile money. Read our guides on the best church management software for Kenya, Nigeria, and South Africa for more options.
Do any Pushpay alternatives support WhatsApp?
Among the major US-built alternatives covered in this article, none offer built-in WhatsApp integration. These platforms rely on email, SMS, push notifications, and in-app messaging. For churches where WhatsApp is the primary communication channel, this is a critical factor. Read our deep dive on WhatsApp as a church communication tool.